Thomas Tuchel Faces Key Selection Challenges Ahead of England’s World Cup Opener Against Croatia

After a series of disappointments in major tournaments under Gareth Southgate, Thomas Tuchel is now charged with the task of ending England’s 60-year wait for silverware at the 2026 World Cup.

Tuchel led the Three Lions through a flawless qualification campaign, winning all eight matches without conceding a single goal, and comfortably topped their group ahead of Albania, Serbia, Latvia, and Andorra.

Ranked fourth in the world by FIFA, England arrived in the United States earlier this month and secured back-to-back victories over New Zealand and Costa Rica in their final warm-up matches.

England defeated Costa Rica 3-0 last week, and Tuchel is expected to maintain a similar lineup when the 1966 champions take on Croatia in their opening Group L match in Dallas on Wednesday.

While star players like Harry Kane, Declan Rice, and Jordan Pickford are likely to be automatic selections, Tuchel faces four critical selection dilemmas that could influence his starting eleven.

Bellingham or Rogers for the No.10 Role?

© Iconsport / PA Images.

A key tactical question for Tuchel is whether to start Jude Bellingham or Morgan Rogers in the central attacking midfield role. Both players are close friends but bring different attributes to the pitch.

Rogers had an impressive season with Aston Villa, contributing significantly to their Europa League triumph with 14 goals and 12 assists across 55 appearances. He was also a consistent presence in Tuchel’s England squad during World Cup qualifying.

In contrast, Bellingham had a challenging season at Real Madrid marred by injuries and missed trophies. Nonetheless, he remains a pivotal figure within the squad due to his previous impactful performances on international stages.

The 22-year-old showcased his potential during the friendly against Costa Rica and has reportedly impressed during training sessions. This performance may secure him the starting No.10 role for the match against Croatia.

Saka or Madueke on the Right Wing?

© Iconsport / Azzuu.

Bukayo Saka typically features prominently on England’s teamsheet; however, concerns about his fitness have opened up competition from Arsenal teammate Noni Madueke for the right-wing position.

Saka has been managing an ongoing Achilles injury which raises doubts about his ability to play a full match during this summer’s World Cup. Tuchel has indicated that Saka is unlikely to complete 90 minutes.

Despite this, Saka insists he is “ready to go”, expressing confidence that he feels better than he has in recent months and plans to push through any discomfort to represent his country.

The decision on whether Saka starts against Croatia will ultimately hinge on his fitness level; even at around 70% fit, Tuchel may still opt for him given the significance of this Group L fixture.

Rashford or Gordon for Left Wing?

© Imago / Focus Images, Icon Sportswire.

The left-wing position sees Marcus Rashford competing with Anthony Gordon for a starting spot. Rashford has been Tuchel’s go-to option since taking charge and enters this tournament following an impressive season with Barcelona where he contributed to 28 goals (14 goals and 14 assists).

The experienced Rashford has accumulated 72 caps over his international career but faces stiff competition from Gordon, who recently made a high-profile move to Barcelona himself—potentially as Rashford’s successor at Camp Nou.

Gordon finished last season with Newcastle as their top scorer with 17 goals and made an impact during England’s warm-up against Costa Rica by scoring a penalty in Kane’s absence. However, it seems likely that Rashford will be favored to start in England’s World Cup opener.

Guehi, Konsa or Stones: Who Will Partner at Centre-Back?

© Imago.

Marc Guehi of Manchester City was once seen as a certain starter in Tuchel’s defense but did not feature against Costa Rica, casting doubt on his inclusion against Croatia.

Ezri Konsa has proven himself through solid performances during qualifying and could earn his place alongside either Guehi or John Stones. Stones’ selection raised eyebrows due to limited game time with Manchester City but remains highly regarded by Tuchel due to his experience—boasting 89 caps including appearances across five major tournaments.

The versatile Stones appears poised to partner Konsa at center-back as they prepare for this crucial opening match.